Hablamos Español – Մենք խոսում ենք հայերեն – Мы говорим по-русски

Available By Phone 24/7

Call

Nearly $2 Billion in Alleged California Healthcare Fraud. What Can Prosecutors Actually Prove?

Nearly $2 billion is a number built for headlines. For a healthcare professional facing federal charges, the more urgent question is how much of that amount prosecutors can support with evidence and connect to that person.

The federal healthcare fraud takedown in California involves 15 defendants, including six medical professionals, and allegations extending well beyond hospice care. As reported by ABC7, the cases include purported substance abuse treatment programs, allegedly unnecessary artery procedures, and hospice services. Its reporter witnessed federal agents carrying out an arrest in Tarzana.

For Ruzanna Poghosyan, managing attorney of RP Defense Law, APC, the size of the announcement makes close examination of the numbers especially important. Amounts billed, amounts paid, and legally attributable fraud loss answer different questions. For someone whose freedom is at stake, the defense has to examine each one.

Hospices Are Only Part of the Story

Hospice investigations have attracted considerable attention in Southern California. This takedown shows how broadly federal prosecutors are reviewing healthcare businesses and the payments moving through them.

Becker’s coverage outlines allegations involving addiction treatment facilities, vascular procedures, hospice companies, genetic testing, and prescription drugs. The cases involve both government healthcare programs and commercial insurers.

The largest alleged scheme involves more than $1.6 billion in substance abuse treatment claims. Other cases concern Medicare billing for artery procedures and hospice services. Authorities also announced an indictment involving a previously charged Medi-Cal pharmacy scheme. These are separate prosecutions brought together in one enforcement announcement.

A healthcare fraud investigation can therefore reach physicians, pharmacies, rehabilitation facilities, home health agencies, clinics, and other providers whose claims come under scrutiny. Private insurance billing can also become part of a federal case. 

“Providers should pay attention to the breadth of these investigations,” Poghosyan said. “The focus extends beyond one type of facility. Investigators are examining how patients enter treatment, what services are documented, who authorizes those services, and how the claims are submitted.”

For a person accused of insurance fraud, understanding the specific allegation is essential. A claim for treatment that never occurred presents different factual questions from an allegation that a procedure occurred but was medically unnecessary.

Investigators Can Start With the Billing Data

One of the cases illustrates how an investigation can begin with reimbursement patterns.

Becker’s describes a vascular procedure investigation identified through data analytics that flagged an unusually high volume of atherectomy billing. Prosecutors allege a surgeon and chiropractor participated in a scheme involving medically unnecessary procedures at Los Angeles County clinics.

Billing data can identify patterns worth investigating. Evaluating those patterns requires the underlying patient records, clinical decisions, and business practices.

The defense may need to look closely at how investigators selected comparison providers, which claims they counted, and whether the data accurately identifies the professional who performed or authorized a service.

“A billing pattern can raise a question. It does not answer every question,” Poghosyan said. “We need to see the patient files, the clinical findings, the claims history, and the methodology investigators used. If the government says a provider’s volume proves fraud, the defense has to examine that conclusion.”

That review may also uncover differences between what a clinician documented and what a billing system ultimately submitted.

“Who selected the code? Who entered the provider information? Was a claim corrected or resubmitted?” Poghosyan said. “Those details matter when someone is being accused of knowingly submitting fraudulent claims.”

Billed, Paid, and Lost Are Three Different Calculations

The announcement’s overall figure should not be treated as a single, court-established loss attributable to every defendant. CBS Los Angeles covered the charges involving government and private healthcare claims.

An amount billed reflects what was submitted for reimbursement. The amount paid reflects what an insurer or government program actually disbursed. A sentencing loss calculation requires further legal and factual analysis.

A submitted claim may be denied, reduced, corrected, or withdrawn. An insurer may pay less than the provider charged. A review may also involve disputes over whether services were provided, whether they were necessary, and which claims were fraudulent.

“The amount billed isn’t necessarily the amount paid, and neither automatically establishes the loss attributable to fraud,” Poghosyan said. “Before accepting a total, we need to understand what it includes.”

That work can involve matching individual claims to payment records, checking for duplicate entries, and comparing the government’s calculations with clinical documentation.

“If a spreadsheet contains thousands of claims, we need to know how those claims were selected,” she said. “Were corrected submissions counted twice? Are unrelated services included? What evidence supports treating each claim as fraudulent? The defense has to work through those questions.”

Unpaid Claims Can Still Matter at Sentencing

The difference between billing and payment does not mean unpaid claims are irrelevant.

Federal fraud guidelines generally use the greater of actual loss or intended loss. Intended loss concerns financial harm the defendant purposely sought to cause, even where that harm did not occur. For federal healthcare offenses involving government programs, fraudulent bills can serve as evidence sufficient to establish intended loss unless rebutted.

The defense must therefore review both the financial records and the evidence of intent. Showing that Medicare rejected a claim may not, by itself, resolve the sentencing issue.

“You cannot defend the loss calculation simply by saying the insurer did not pay,” Poghosyan said. “You have to examine what the government claims our client intended, which bills it identifies as fraudulent, and what evidence supports or challenges that position.”

For someone facing a federal prosecution, this work can become a substantial part of the defense.

A Loss Calculation Can Affect Years of Someone’s Life

Loss amounts can increase the advisory sentencing guideline calculation in federal fraud cases. They are not the only consideration, and a headline figure does not translate automatically into a particular prison sentence. But an unsupported calculation can have serious consequences if it goes unchallenged.

For the person accused, disputes over the numbers can be as consequential as disputes over the underlying transactions.

“We’re potentially talking about years of someone’s life,” Poghosyan said. “A loss figure needs to be examined with the same care as any other evidence that could affect a client’s freedom.”

In a white-collar case involving several participants, counsel must also determine which conduct and losses can properly be attributed to the individual client.

A physician, marketer, owner, and outside biller may have different responsibilities and different knowledge. Their involvement may also cover different periods.

“A person’s connection to a business does not answer every question about their responsibility,” Poghosyan said. “When did they become involved? What did they agree to do? What information did they have? Those questions belong in the defense’s examination of the alleged loss.”

Ruzanna Poghosyan: “I’m More Interested in the Numbers Prosecutors Can Actually Prove”

An enforcement announcement presents the government’s allegations. The defense must examine the evidence behind them, including the records that may challenge the prosecution’s account.

In healthcare cases, that can require reviewing patient charts, reimbursement histories, contracts, referral arrangements, and communications between businesses. Where allegations include money laundering, counsel must also trace the specific transfers and the purpose prosecutors attribute to them.

“The $2 billion headline gets everyone’s attention,” Poghosyan said. “I’m more interested in the numbers prosecutors can actually prove.”

That approach keeps the focus on the person facing the case.

“A healthcare professional may be worried about prison, their license, their employees, and their family,” she said. “They need a defense that understands the allegations and is prepared to challenge the evidence, including the calculations that could shape their future.”

RP Defense Law represents individuals facing healthcare fraud investigations and other serious criminal allegations throughout California. The firm reviews each client’s conduct, the government’s evidence, and the financial claims that may affect the case.

Contact RP Defense Law

Ruzanna Poghosyan is available to comment on healthcare fraud investigations, billing data, disputed loss calculations, and federal criminal defense.

If you are facing questions about Medicare, Medi-Cal, private insurance claims, or your role in a healthcare business, contact RP Defense Law to discuss your situation or case. Members of the media can request comment the same way.

The firm’s office is located at 9440 Santa Monica Blvd., Suite 301, Beverly Hills, CA 90210, in the Bank of America Building. 

The commentary in this article reflects the opinions of Ruzanna Poghosyan and is provided for general informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice or create an attorney-client relationship.

Archives

Accolades & Awards

Beverly Hills Office

Bank of America Building
9440 Santa Monica Blvd. #301
Beverly Hills, CA 90210

Request a Confidential Consultation

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
*

© Copyright 2026 RP Criminal Defense. All Rights Reserved.